Well first off, Atomic Moto rocks...had a little trouble selecting the perfect boot for me since I was looking for something that had reasonable protection but yet was comfortable for riding all day and for taking short hikes off of the bike plus I wanted "cool" since it is always hot in Florida :). Atomic Moto recommended the Forma Boulder and they hit the nail on the head. Had to try two different sizes but in the end the Forma sizing guide worked the best for me: https://www.formabootsusa.com/pages/sizing. I have worn several Alpinestars and several Gaerne in the past with the GX-1 being a great bang for your buck but the Forma Boulder is more comfortable, cooler (breathes better) than the others while only giving up a little bit in the protection department. They did take a couple hours to break in...were a little tight to start with but the Form sizing guide worked in the long run. Well worth the break in time and the price :). Thank YOU Atomic Moto.
I had my choices narrowed down to this and the Gaerne because of the flat welt sole construction and wider toe box. Picked this one for both the wife and I as it had many good reviews about the width, was less expensive than the Gaerne and was claimed to have a stiffer sole than the Gaerne. The main purpose is for dual sport riding.
Pros:
The boot is well made. Buckles work very well. Sizing was spot on based on our euro size. They look good too, very much like a work boot to the casual observation with regular pants.
Cons:
Not as wide as the reviews made them sound. They are good in the sense the heel is not ridiculous in order to get a wider forefoot but these could be wider up front for both of us. For reference we both normally wear either Lems or Xero shoes 95% of the time. OF course this is individual specific and just our experience. They also have zero resemblance of trying to keep water out. Skipped the waterproof because of the Texas heat but even water puddles or river crossings with just the splash result in wet feet, however they have kept mud and dirt out.
Would I recommend, yes, if your budget puts you in this price range and you don't need any more width. But if more budget or more width, then pony up and get the Gaerne Balance/G All Terrain. I had tried on the G All Terrain and they felt great. Will be getting a pair in the future. Most importantly will be purchasing from Atomic Moto. Service here is the best I have had in a long time.
These boots are a bit snug in the forefoot area but seem to be loosening up after wearing for a few hours. Quality seems pretty good. Customer service is great.
Pretty stiff new calf is tight for me can't wear my usual knee/shin guards definitely made for slender legs. Toe box is pretty good. Really like the solid feel of the sole.
This is my first set of real motorcycle boots as I've always worn hikers in the past I ride an 83 bmw r80 commuting and on off road trips. I was looking at the balance pro-techs but after talking to Brian we decided the boulder would suit my needs better. I wasn't concerned with waterproofing (i'd rather have something that breathes) and I haven't really gotten these boots wet yet so I can't speak to that aspect of them. I am very impressed with how comfortable they are to walk around in I have been wearing them to work and aside from being a bit warm they are comfortable all day. I did replace the insoles I'll never understand why the boots in this price range don't come with decent insoles it makes such a huge difference. I recently got a plated wr400 and I want to start riding more trails but I will probably get another set of boots for that as these don't offer as much ankle support as an mx boot. In the meantime I am wearing an ankle brace inside the boot per Brians recommendation. My only regret is waiting so long to get them.
Great light feeling boot, have worn around the house for break in haven't rode in them yet but suspect they will be a good choice, Will submit after break in and ride.
So far so good! I've ridden with them in the dry and in the wet. Gortex seems to be doing its job. the boots are quite comfortable right out of the box. Seems like they might run a bit big, my size 13 are a full inch longer than my size 13 Alpinstars. I thought about replacing with size 12 but I like the way they feel on my feet so much I didn't do it. The wider boot combined with the stitching around the sole took a bit to get used to compared to the slim Alpinstars. had to adjust my shifter, which helped.
For the harder stuff I wear Forma's Predator MX boots, but they're (understandably) too stiff when you know you'll be in lighter conditions and may need to help pick up bikes throughout the day. I had been downshifting to Sidi Adventure and Gaerne trials boots, but those aren't protective enough for unpredictable twin track. Enter the Sidi X-Power SC. 4-buckle security, plenty wide toe box (I can't handle Crossfires), and a good balance of TPU and fabric to offer moderate protection while retaining trail maneuverability and comfort. They even do a great job keeping 6-ish inches of muddy water out - I can personally attest to it. No, they're not GoreTex waterproof for adventure rides, and no they're not going to save your feet from a nasty rock strike, but they're similar to a Tech 7 and will readily handle sticks and mild falls while not wearing you down all day like a "ski boot" can. I'd call them a fantastic value when on sale. Tip: consider orthotics or a D3O sole for extra comfort!
Coming out of Gaerne Fastback Endurance boots which, even after extensive break in, never fit my feet comfortably. The SIDI's fit me really well and stay comfortable even after hours on the pegs (My longest ride was about 3 hours but most of it standing). The narrower heel holds my ankle and foot snugly but comfortably. The roomier toe accommodates my wider forefeet and also allows some foot expansion during a long ride. Design is just right, lots of protection but incorporated without making the boots big, heavy and clunky. That makes these really confidence inspiring on the bike as you get good feel for the controls, without sacrificing the protection that you're wearing these for. I don't walk much in my riding boots but did go a short distance on a trail wearing the SIDI's. They aren't uncomfortable but if you plan on doing any more than minimal walking around, bring a pair of walking shoes with you. The materials seem excellent and look like they will last. Personally, I don't see much downside to the glued soles (vs. a stitched on sole) as by the time they wear out, I'll likely be ready for new boots anyway. While everything about these boots seems pretty first class, only time will tell if they will provide longevity. Out of the box, my left boot had a sharp staple protruding enough to go all the way through the insole and poke my heel. An easy fix but something to watch out for. Overall, after a week of riding in these, I am very happy. The X Power SC's provide great protection while not being ungainly to wear. They fit super comfortably and have (other than the staple) since they came out of the box. At $100 off, these seem like an honest bargain.
I gave Atomic Moto a call to get their feedback on potential boot options. After a long chat with Brian, I settled on the Gaerne and couldn’t be happier. It’s a big step up from my A-stars adventure boot. Took a couple rides to get used to the boot but it feels great now!